Constructive reinforcement education is frequently the best and humane way to deal with too much barking. Humane anti-barking devices can be found in two versions or in a combination of each: That said, you should only resort to a shock collar if almost nothing else is Operating, and usually start https://pawpressnews.com/best-dog-deterrent-device-for-dogs-the-ultimate-solution-for-bark-control-and-training